Nothing in the Constitution mentions parties, and no law limits the country to two. Yet every president since 1853 has been a Democrat or a Republican, and every sitting member of Congress belongs to one of the two or, in the case of the Senate’s two independents, votes with one of them on who runs it. The reasons are mostly rules — some built into how Americans vote, and some written since by the parties that benefit.
The rules that keep it at two
Plurality wins, one seat per district
Nearly every American office goes to whoever gets the most votes, even under half, and each district elects one person. A party that comes a close third everywhere wins nothing.
The French political scientist Maurice Duverger observed that this rule tends to produce two parties, because voters abandon a candidate they expect to lose and donors and candidates follow them. It is a tendency, not a law: Britain and Canada use the same rule and keep several parties.
Winner-take-all electoral votes
Forty-eight states and the District of Columbia give all their electoral votes to the statewide winner. Maine and Nebraska award two to the statewide winner and one per congressional district.
A candidate who wins a fifth of the vote in every state wins no electoral votes. Ross Perot won 18.9% in 1992 and none.
Getting on the ballot
States, through laws their legislatures write, list the major parties’ nominees automatically. Other parties and independents must qualify state by state, usually by petition, with deadlines and signature counts that differ in each state.
The cost falls only on candidates outside the two parties, and most of a national campaign’s first year can go to it.
The debate threshold
The Commission on Presidential Debates, founded in 1987 under the sponsorship of the two parties, has required since 2000 that a candidate average at least 15% across five national polls.
No candidate outside the two parties has appeared in a general-election presidential debate since Ross Perot in 1992. Every court challenge to the rule has failed.
Public money
Federal funding for a general-election campaign goes in full to the major-party nominees ($123.5 million each for 2024, if they accept it). A minor party qualifies for a share only if its nominee won between 5% and 25% of the vote in the previous election.
The money follows the last election, not the current one. Perot’s 8.4% in 1996 earned the Reform Party about $12.5 million for 2000.
Fusion, mostly banned
Fusion lets a minor party nominate a major party’s candidate on its own ballot line, so its voters can back a likely winner and still be counted. It was once legal everywhere and was banned in most states by the early 20th century.
It remains legal and in regular use only in New York and Connecticut, and partly legal in California, Pennsylvania and Maryland.
Sources: Federal Election Commission (public funding, the 5–25% rule and the 2024 grant); the Commission on Presidential Debates’ criteria and the court rulings upholding them; Wikipedia’s history of electoral fusion. Ballot-access rules are set by each state and change often, so this page does not tabulate them.
Third parties win in a different way
Because they so rarely win offices, third parties have mattered mostly by moving one of the big two. The Free Soil Party of 1848 fed into the new Republican Party; the Populists of the 1890s ended up endorsing the Democrats’ nominee in 1896; Ross Perot made the federal deficit the center of his 1992 campaign. The one new party ever to become a major party, the Republicans, did it in 1854 by replacing the Whigs outright, not by building up alongside them.
What this page is not
It is about the parties and candidates outside the two, and the voters who reject both labels. Ranked-choice voting and the ballot measures that adopted and banned it are Ballot Measures & Direct Democracy; why the two parties have moved apart is Political Polarization; how electoral votes are won and lost is The Electoral College; the mechanics of casting a ballot are How America Votes; and what polls of three-way races can and cannot tell you is Polling.