We use analytics cookies to understand how readers use the site. They only run if you accept. Privacy policy.
The S&P composite since January 1871, with consumer price inflation removed. The axis is logarithmic: each gridline is roughly three times the one below it, so a constant percentage gain draws a constant slope and the 1870s are legible against the 2020s. On a straight axis the first hundred years lie flat on the floor and the chart says the market did nothing until about 1990, which is false.
Robert Shiller’s reconstruction of the S&P composite, monthly from January 1871 and averaged here to years. Each monthly value is itself an average of that month’s daily closes, except the last, which is a single day — October 2026 is the 2 October close. 2026 is ten months, and is marked as partial wherever it appears.
A dollar of the index in January 1871 is worth about 64 dollars today in constant money. The same dollar, with every dividend used to buy more shares, is worth about 44,043 — a real return of 7.1% a year. The difference is not a rounding choice. It is most of the answer.
The reason is that dividends used to be the point. The yield averaged 5.32% from 1871 to 1949 and 4.06% from 1950 to 1989; it has averaged 1.76% since 2010 and 1.15% for January to June 2026, the lowest annual figure in the record. A shareholder in 1930 was being paid to wait. A shareholder now is almost entirely relying on the price.